Nine years ago, I wrote a series of essays for the Embodied Faith blog. Discovering that blog is no longer available online, I wanted to repost them here. This is the third of four; the first is here.
“Rejoice in the Lord always; again I will say, Rejoice. Let your gentleness be known to everyone. The Lord is near. Do not worry about anything, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God. And the peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus.” – Philippians 4:4-7
“The peace of God it is no peace.” (William Alexander Percy, 1924) This phrase captures the strange calling we have to be peacemakers in the midst of war, to seek out the last and the least, to put ourselves in harm’s way. Jesus did exactly that in the incarnation. And yet, it is not masochism or self-punishment or even self-disregard. It is a way of bringing about transformation. It is finding a point of conflict and stepping in strategically to sort things out. No doubt God does this miraculously, but Jesus also does it prosaically, and we can as well. “Martial arts” or “embodied mindfulness” or, as I think of it, “moving meditation” integrates body, mind, and spirit so that we can act in the world. The first way we can do this involves using the body for spiritual learning, and that’s what I’d like to talk about here. Exploring opposition can teach us about harmony. And knowing how conflict works can help us foster peace.
In martial arts, one of my favorite examples is the “unbendable arm.” It helps us explore the difference between the effort we put in and the effect we produce. It also reveals the results of internal conflict. The core principle is this – a relaxed arm can be stronger than a rigid one.
Two people stand face to face. The first places their right arm on the other’s right shoulder – across the body. The first person tightens their muscles and tries to hold the arm rigidly in place while the second person tries to bend the arm. [Don’t try this at home; it can be dangerous. If you must, be sure that the first person starts with their arm slightly bent, elbow pointed down to avoid injury.]
In most cases, the second person can bend the arm, sometimes easily, sometimes with a great deal of effort. Now the first person tries again, with the arm relaxed (even bent). This time they don’t tense or resist; they simply breathe and focus on extending energy through the arm. The arm becomes much harder to bend… or even move. It can take a little practice to figure this out, but I find most students master it – at least at a basic level – within an hour or two. Advanced practitioners can hold their arm extended, bend and straighten, and even move side to side – their partner moving with them.
It seems amazing. How does it work? I find it easiest to understand in terms of muscles. When you tense your arm, when you think about using strength, you are engaging muscles on both sides. You are fighting yourself. And when you fight against yourself, you are more easily overcome (Mark 3:25).
In Chinese medicine, I might say that “mind leads energy.” Shen leads chi. Li, or muscular tension, blocks the chi, stopping it from flowing as the mind directs. The unbendable arm is a simple, small-scale physical demonstration of a broader principle. When you work against yourself, it is easier to be moved by an outside force.
Alternatively, we might imagine a team working together. If they are not in harmony, then the efforts of different members will conflict. Less is accomplished. People who don’t cooperate stop things from happening. More to the point, their energy is devoted to within group tension, and not to whole group action. The same principle applies to companies, countries, and even congregations.
A healthy church, at harmony with itself, is easily directed by its head, Christ. When it works against itself, the will of the head is harder to work out. So, if you prefer, we can talk about the Spirit instead of chi. I like this metaphor because it captures the idea that all muscles are good and necessary, but only some are called for at any one time. In the church, all of us intend the good and are driven by the Spirit, but tension arises when we don’t coordinate. Even when we are opposed, we can see ourselves as part of one body (I Cor 12).
You may be familiar with the idea of Yin and Yang from Chinese philosophy. Yin and Yang do not represent good and evil, antagonism, or dualism – though they get used that way by the public. The symbol arises from the sunny and shady sides of a hill. It captures the idea of seeing something as both a single, organic whole, and as a set of complementary parts. Yin and Yang speak to the seeming division of things that are fundamentally one, like the muscles of the arm.
Yin and Yang can also represent the intermediate place of life between sky and ground, or the way that Shen (Mind) and Jing (Body) come together dynamically in the chi. Chi is not some mystical immaterial force. It is, rather, the intertwined operation of mind and body working in the world. So, I can speak of personal chi or spirit or energy, which flows from my intent, smoothly and powerfully when I am mindfully embodied. I can also speak of the Spirit of God, which flows through the church, smoothly and powerfully when we are attuned to the mind of Christ. Or we can talk about how energy gets bottled up, crashes into itself, and causes all kinds of trouble, when the parts don’t work together. However we speak of it, there is a path to harmony worth exploring. It may not always be the answer, but it should always be an option.